HSR 3.8 Fugue vs Lingsha: Break Team Pull Guide 2026

Version 3.8 Break Meta & Phase 3 Banners

Break effect meta dominates Memory of Chaos and Pure Fiction in 3.8. Phase 2 (Jan 7-28, 2026) features Fugue (5★ Fire Nihility) and Lingsha (5★ Fire Abundance) with 4-stars Natasha, Sampo, Arlan—limited value for break builders.

Phase 3 transitions to Aglaea/Sunday reruns (Jan 28-Feb 12) with Tingyun, Yukong, Dan Heng. Honkai Star Rail Oneiric Shards top up via BitTopup helps manage stellar jade across banner phases with secure transactions and competitive pricing.

Current Break Meta

Break compositions dominate endgame through Super Break mechanics converting toughness damage into substantial multipliers. Firefly leverages innate Super Break; Boothill needs external enablers. Meta demands 200%+ Break Effect on DPS, with supports providing buffs, debuffs, and toughness reduction.

Ruan Mei remains premium break support (50% Weakness Break Efficiency, team-wide Break Effect scaling). Her singular presence creates constraints—you need sustain units contributing break damage or additional amplifiers. This gap defines Fugue and Lingsha's positioning.

Why They Matter

Fugue introduces Exo-Toughness bars enabling repeated Super Break triggers and weakness-ignoring toughness damage. Her Talent adds 40% enemy max toughness as breakable Exo-Toughness, converting ally attacks into 100% Super Break damage. Extends break windows significantly.

Lingsha solves sustain slot inefficiency. Traditional healers contribute minimal damage between heals. Lingsha's Fuyuan summon (90 SPD, max 5 actions) deals 75% ATK Fire AoE + 75% ATK single-target to Fire-weak enemies while healing. Ultimate applies Befog: +25% Break DMG taken for 2 turns.

Fugue Complete Analysis

Level 80 stats: 1125 HP, 582 ATK, 557 DEF, 102 SPD. Kit revolves around Break Effect amplification, weakness-ignoring toughness reduction, Exo-Toughness generation.

Skill Kit

Foxian Prayer (Skill): Grants ally 30% Break Effect + 50% Toughness Reduction ignoring weakness for 3 turns. Allows Fire-weak enemies to take toughness damage from all elements, accelerating break cycles. 30% Break Effect stacks multiplicatively, pushing DPS toward 250%+ thresholds.

Ultimate (130 Energy): 200% ATK AoE Fire damage ignoring weakness. Activates every 3-4 cycles with Energy Regen Rope. Ensures contribution against all enemy types.

Cloudflame Luster (Talent): Adds 40% enemy max toughness as Exo-Toughness. Ally attacks convert to 100% Super Break damage—creates permanent Super Break states. Works independently of weakness breaks.

Technique: Applies Daze (10s), advances action 40%, reduces enemy DEF for 2 turns. Action advance ensures first-turn skill application.

Break Effect Mechanics

30% Break Effect buff applies additively before multiplicative calculations. Firefly at 200% base becomes 230%—roughly 15% more Super Break damage per instance. With Ruan Mei, teams reach 280%+ Break Effect.

Exo-Toughness functions as secondary bar after initial break. Enemies with 40% additional toughness require more hits, but each hit triggers Super Break. Creates 5-6 additional instances per enemy, effectively doubling break phase damage.

Optimal Build

Target 220%+ Break Effect, 67% Effect Hit Rate, 145+ SPD (Talia ornament threshold for +20% Break Effect).

Relics:

• 2pc Thief + 2pc Iron Cavalry: 32% Break Effect + 30% Super Break DMG vs broken enemies

• Talia Kingdom: +20% Break Effect at 145+ SPD, +5% baseline

Main Stats: Break Effect body, SPD boots, Fire DMG%/ATK% sphere, Energy Regen rope

Best Light Cones

Long Road Leads Home (Signature): 60% Break Effect + 18% Break DMG taken debuff (max 2 stacks = 36%). Dual buffer-debuffer role.

Alternatives:

• Resolution Shines As Pearls of Sweat (4★): 48% Break Effect at S5—80% signature value
• Memories of the Past (4★): 56% Break Effect at S5 + Energy Regen

Lingsha Complete Analysis

Level 80 stats: 1358 HP, 679 ATK, 436 DEF, 98 SPD. Higher HP/ATK than traditional Abundance units, supporting healing and damage.

Skill Kit

Skill: 80% ATK Fire AoE, heals all for 14% ATK +420, advances Fuyuan 20%. Maintains SP neutrality while contributing toughness damage.

Fuyuan Summon: Operates at 90 SPD, max 5 actions. Each action: 75% ATK Fire AoE + 75% ATK single-target to Fire-weak enemies. Contributes ~40% of Lingsha's total damage vs Fire-weak content.

Ultimate: 150% ATK AoE Fire, heals all for 12% ATK +360, applies Befog (+25% Break DMG taken, 2 turns). Debuff multiplies with all break sources. 3-4 cycle rotation.

Technique: Summons Fuyuan + applies Befog for 2 turns at battle start. Immediate amplified break damage.

Dual Role Efficiency

Eliminates sustain slot tax. Gallagher provides adequate healing but negligible damage. Lingsha maintains equivalent healing (14% ATK +420 per skill) while adding 150-200% ATK worth of Fire damage per cycle through Fuyuan.

25% Break DMG debuff = pseudo-support. When Firefly deals 100k Super Break, Befog increases to 125k—25k gain per trigger. Across 8-10 instances per cycle: 200k-250k indirect damage through debuff alone.

Optimal Build

Target 200% Break Effect, 134+ SPD, sufficient ATK% for healing scaling.

Relics:

• 2pc Iron Cavalry + 2pc Messenger: 16% Break Effect + 12% SPD
• Forge of Kalpagni Lantern: +6% SPD + 40% Break Effect vs Fire-weak (1 turn)

Main Stats: ATK% body, SPD boots, ATK%/HP% sphere, Energy Regen rope

Best Light Cones

Scent Alone Stays True (Signature): 60% Break Effect + 18% DMG taken debuff at 150%+ Break Effect. Stacks multiplicatively with Befog.

Alternatives:

• Post-Op Conversation (4★): Energy Regen + healing increase at S5
• Quid Pro Quo (4★): Energy to allies when using skill

Firefly Teams: Fugue vs Lingsha

Firefly + Fugue Team

Core: Firefly + Fugue + Ruan Mei + Lingsha

Triple-layer amplification. Fugue: 30% BE + Exo-Toughness. Ruan Mei: 50% Weakness Break Efficiency. Lingsha: 25% Break DMG debuff. Firefly operates at 250%+ Break Effect.

Rotation:

1. Fugue Technique → Lingsha Technique (Befog)
2. Fugue Skill on Firefly (30% BE, 50% toughness reduction)
3. Ruan Mei Skill
4. Firefly enhanced attacks (Super Break)
5. Lingsha Skill (heal + Fuyuan advance)
6. Repeat with ultimates every 3-4 cycles

Achieves 8-10 Super Break instances per enemy, 80k-120k damage each. Total cycle damage: 1.2-1.5M vs single targets (MoC floor 12).

Firefly + Lingsha Without Fugue

Alternative: Firefly + Ruan Mei + Lingsha + Harmonic Trailblazer

HMC provides free Super Break enablement. Sacrifices Exo-Toughness but maintains core functionality. Damage decreases 25-30% vs Fugue variant. Lingsha's 25% debuff becomes proportionally more significant. MoC floor 12 viable with better relics.

Damage Comparison

MoC floor 12 boss (standardized relics, 55% crit value equivalent in BE substats):

• Firefly + Fugue + Ruan Mei + Lingsha: 1.35M avg cycle damage, 4-cycle clear
• Firefly + Ruan Mei + Lingsha + HMC: 950k avg cycle damage, 5-6 cycle clear

400k differential from Exo-Toughness enabling 3-4 additional Super Break triggers. Fugue reduces clear times by 1-2 cycles.

Boothill Teams: Fugue vs Lingsha

Boothill's single-target specialization requires different priorities. Enhanced basics deal massive break damage but lack native Super Break enablement.

Boothill + Fugue Synergy

Fugue's weakness-ignoring toughness reduction proves exceptional for Physical typing. Many enemies resist Physical—Fugue's 50% reduction allows efficient breaking of non-Physical-weak enemies.

Optimal: Boothill + Fugue + Ruan Mei + Lingsha

Enhanced basics trigger Super Break during Exo-Toughness: 100k-150k per hit at 220%+ Break Effect. Extended break windows enable 6-8 enhanced basics per enemy.

SP economy positive: Fugue/Ruan Mei SP-neutral, Lingsha generates SP via basic heals. Boothill consumes 2-3 SP per enhanced rotation—sustainable.

Boothill + Lingsha Balance

Lingsha's Fire typing creates elemental coverage. Fuyuan handles Fire-weak targets while Boothill focuses Physical-weak. 25% Break DMG debuff pushes individual breaks toward 180k+ damage.

Alternative: Boothill + Ruan Mei + Lingsha + Bronya

Bronya enables additional enhanced rotations via action advance. Sacrifices break ceiling for consistent damage distribution.

Single-Target Performance

MoC single-target bosses:

• Boothill + Fugue + Ruan Mei + Lingsha: 1.8M single-target cycle damage, 3-cycle elite clear
• Boothill + Ruan Mei + Lingsha + Bronya: 1.6M single-target cycle damage, 3-4 cycle clear

Fugue provides 200k additional damage per cycle. Bronya offers flexibility vs speed-tuned enemies.

Advanced Synergies

Ruan Mei + Fugue Double Support

Maximum break amplification but demands efficient healers like Lingsha.

Synergies:

• 50% Weakness Break Efficiency + 50% Toughness Reduction = 100% faster breaks
• Break Effect scaling + 30% BE buff = 280%+ on DPS
• RES PEN + DEF reduction = multiplicative damage

Most effective in Pure Fiction AoE scenarios. May overcap buffs in MoC single-target—single-support more resource-efficient.

Lingsha vs Gallagher

Healing: Comparable—both maintain HP through floor 12 Damage: Lingsha deals 40-50% more via Fuyuan Break Amplification: Lingsha's 25% debuff vs Gallagher's minimal support SP Economy: Similar—both generate SP via basic heals

Gallagher's advantage: accessibility as 4★ (zero jade cost). Lingsha = optimization upgrade, not mandatory.

Future-Proofing

Version 3.9+ will introduce additional break characters. Fugue's Exo-Toughness = unique mechanic unlikely to be replicated soon. Lingsha's hybrid design positions well for future archetypes.

Investment Priority:

• Fugue: Higher ceiling for dedicated break teams, essential for max Firefly/Boothill damage
• Lingsha: Broader applicability, sustain slot efficiency for account-wide progression

Pull Priority Framework

Scenario 1: Firefly but No Ruan Mei

Recommendation: Prioritize Fugue

Without Ruan Mei, Firefly lacks critical buffs. Fugue partially compensates via 30% BE + Exo-Toughness. Pair with HMC + Lingsha/Gallagher for viable MoC performance.

Expected output: 70-75% of optimal Ruan Mei teams—sufficient for floor 12. Save jade for future Ruan Mei rerun.

Scenario 2: Boothill Mains

Recommendation: Both if Possible, Prioritize Fugue if Limited

Boothill benefits from both. Fugue enables weakness-ignoring damage + Exo-Toughness. Lingsha provides sustain + 25% amplification.

If choosing one: Fugue offers unique value unavailable elsewhere. Boothill functions with Gallagher sustain but struggles without Fugue vs non-Physical-weak content.

Scenario 3: Established Break Teams

Recommendation: Evaluate Current Sustain

Firefly + Ruan Mei + HMC + Gallagher → prioritize Fugue for 30-40% damage increase.

Players with premium sustain may find Lingsha redundant unless seeking optimization. However, 25% debuff stacks with existing buffs for measurable increase.

Scenario 4: F2P Limited Jade

Recommendation: Single Copy Fugue, Skip Lingsha

F2P constraints demand unique mechanics. Fugue's Exo-Toughness + weakness-ignoring support unavailable through 4★ alternatives. Gallagher adequately fulfills sustain at zero cost.

Allocate toward single Fugue (worst-case 28,800 jade for guarantee at 180 pulls). Skip signature—Resolution Shines provides 80% effectiveness at 4★ accessibility. Buy HSR Oneiric Shards online via BitTopup's secure platform with competitive pricing to reach guarantee thresholds.

Eidolon Value

Fugue:

• E1: 50% Exo-Toughness (from 40%)—10-15% damage increase, moderate value
• E2: Extended buffs + DEF ignore—20-25% damage increase, high value for spenders

Lingsha:

• E1: 30% Befog (from 25%)—5-8% team damage increase, low priority
• E2: Fuyuan additional actions—15-20% personal damage increase, moderate value

Both function optimally at E0. Eidolons show diminishing returns vs acquiring new characters. F2P/low-spenders: prioritize E0 copies over constellations.

Resource Investment

Trace Materials

Fugue:

• Obsidian of Dread (Stagnant Shadow: Shape of Ire)
• Artifex's Module (Crimson Calyx)
• Tracks of Destiny (talent levels 8-10)

Lingsha:

• Ascendant Debris (Stagnant Shadow: Shape of Perdition)
• Safeguard's Insignia (Crimson Calyx)
• Tracks of Destiny (talent levels 8-10)

Pre-farm during Phase 1 to immediately level upon acquisition. Prioritize talent levels to 8 minimum—Fugue's Skill/Talent, Lingsha's Skill/Ultimate.

Relic Farming

Fugue Priority:

1. Talia ornament first (guaranteed BE main stat)
2. Alternate Thief/Iron Cavalry domains
3. Target BE body, SPD boots, Energy Regen rope (non-negotiable)
4. Accept ATK%/Fire DMG% sphere based on availability

Lingsha Priority:

1. Forge of Kalpagni ornament (SPD + conditional BE)
2. Focus Iron Cavalry domain (useful for multiple break characters)
3. Target ATK% body, SPD boots, Energy Regen rope
4. Prioritize ATK% sphere for healing-damage balance

Relic farming = 60-70% of character power. Invest 2-3 weeks stamina before considering fully built.

Stellar Jade Cost

Worst-Case (Losing 50/50):

• Character guarantee: 28,800 jade (180 pulls)
• Signature LC guarantee: 25,600 jade (160 pulls)
• Total worst-case: 54,400 jade

Average:

• Character: 19,200 jade (120 pulls avg including soft pity)
• LC: 16,000 jade (100 pulls avg)
• Total average: 35,200 jade

Budget Planning:

• Phase 2 duration: 21 days (Jan 7-28)
• Daily jade income: ~100 (dailies, events, compensation)
• Phase 2 F2P income: ~2,100 jade
• Requires pre-saved 26k-52k jade depending on luck

Common Mistakes

Myth: Must Have Both Fugue and Ruan Mei

While they synergize excellently, running both creates support overcrowding. Most break comps function optimally with one dedicated break support + sustain + DPS. Dual-support works in specific scenarios (Pure Fiction AoE) but isn't universally mandatory.

Fugue + HMC provides sufficient support for Firefly without Ruan Mei. Ruan Mei + Gallagher sustains Boothill adequately without Fugue. Evaluate specific DPS and available characters.

Mistake: Ignoring SP Management

Break teams consume SP rapidly. Fugue/Ruan Mei operate SP-neutral, but improper rotation creates droughts. Lingsha generates SP via basic heals—valuable for SP-hungry comps.

Optimal SP Flow:

• Maintain 3+ SP before DPS enhanced state
• Use support basics during DPS downtime
• Prioritize Lingsha basics when SP drops below 2
• Avoid consecutive skills from multiple supports

Misconception: Lingsha Can't Compete with Pure Supports

Lingsha's hybrid design creates perception of underperformance. Actual data shows she contributes 70-80% of pure support damage amplification (via 25% debuff) while providing 100% required sustain. Combined value exceeds separate healer + support.

In 4-character teams, slot efficiency determines power. Lingsha's dual functionality enables two damage-focused characters or double break support configs impossible with traditional healers.

Overlooked: Free Break Support Options

HMC provides free Super Break enablement. Gallagher offers zero-cost sustain adequate for floor 12. Players can build functional break teams using Firefly/Boothill + HMC + Gallagher + flex without spending jade on supports.

This F2P config clears MoC floor 12 with proper relics (220%+ BE on DPS, 160+ SPD on supports). Premium characters provide optimization and comfort, not mandatory requirements.

Long-Term Meta Projection

Version 3.9+ Considerations

Break mechanics show no declining relevance. Recent endgame features massive HP/toughness bars, favoring break over traditional crit comps. Fugue's Exo-Toughness future-proofs against toughness inflation.

Lingsha's hybrid design aligns with developer trends toward slot-efficient characters. Future Abundance units will likely follow similar patterns, but Lingsha's Fire typing and break-specific debuffs ensure continued value.

Upcoming Break Characters

Version 3.9 leaks suggest additional break-oriented characters. However, Fugue's unique Exo-Toughness and Lingsha's specific 25% debuff occupy distinct niches unlikely to be powercrept. New characters will complement existing supports rather than replace.

Investment in Fugue/Lingsha remains safe through version 4.0. Break archetypes show staying power comparable to Hypercarry/Follow-up compositions viable across multiple cycles.

Investment ROI

Fugue Long-Term:

• Unique mechanics, no alternatives
• Essential for max Firefly/Boothill damage
• Limited applicability outside break teams
• Estimated relevance: 6-8 version cycles

Lingsha Long-Term:

• Hybrid design applicable to multiple archetypes
• BiS sustain for break teams
• Usable in non-break comps requiring Fire damage
• Estimated relevance: 8-10 version cycles

Lingsha edges ahead in versatility; Fugue provides higher peak performance in specialized comps. Weight decision based on account needs—specialists benefit from Fugue, generalists favor Lingsha.

Maximize Pulls: Jade & Top-Up Strategy

Efficient Jade Management

Phase 2's 21-day duration provides limited jade accumulation. Audit current reserves and calculate guarantee probability:

Guarantee Calculation:

• Current jade ÷ 160 = available pulls
• Pulls since last 5★ = pity progress
• 90 - pity progress = pulls to guarantee

Soft pity begins at 74 pulls with dramatically increased 5★ rates. Players at 60+ pity have ~50% chance within 20 pulls.

BitTopup Advantage

BitTopup offers secure Oneiric Shard top-ups with competitive pricing and fast delivery, helping reach guarantee thresholds during limited windows. Excellent customer service and high ratings ensure reliable transactions.

Strategic timing maximizes value—purchase during first week to confirm results and adjust spending based on early 5★ acquisition. Avoid last-minute top-ups risking processing delays before Jan 28 Phase 3 transition.

Phase 3 Considerations

Aglaea/Sunday reruns (Jan 28-Feb 12) offer alternative investments. Consider:

• Aglaea's role in current roster
• Sunday's support capabilities for existing DPS
• Long-term acquisition goals across 3.8-4.0

Skipping Phase 2 remains valid for players with functional break teams using free alternatives. Jade saved carries forward to Phase 3 and 3.9.

FAQ

Is Fugue better than Lingsha for Firefly teams?

Fugue provides higher damage ceiling (30-40% increase) via Exo-Toughness + 30% BE buffs but requires separate sustain. Lingsha offers sustain + 25% Break DMG amplification in single slot. For pure damage: Fugue wins. For slot efficiency: Lingsha excels. Optimal config uses both with Ruan Mei.

Should I pull Fugue or Lingsha for Boothill?

Fugue takes priority—weakness-ignoring toughness reduction enables break damage vs non-Physical-weak enemies. Boothill struggles without Fugue's support in content lacking Physical-weak targets. Lingsha provides valuable sustain + 25% buff but replaceable by Gallagher if limited. Acquire Fugue first, add Lingsha later if jade permits.

Can Lingsha replace Gallagher in break teams?

Yes, Lingsha provides superior performance via higher damage + 25% Break DMG debuff. Healing output comparable. Lingsha = optimization upgrade, not mandatory replacement—Gallagher suffices for MoC floor 12. Upgrade when seeking damage ceiling improvements or when Gallagher's limited break support becomes bottleneck.

Does Fugue work with Ruan Mei in same team?

Yes, they synergize excellently: 100% faster break cycles via combined buffs. Dual-support works best with self-sustaining DPS or efficient healers like Lingsha. Team: Firefly/Boothill + Fugue + Ruan Mei + Lingsha for max break damage. Represents optimal break team in 3.8.

Is Fugue must-pull for break players?

Fugue provides substantial increases (30-40%) but isn't mandatory. HMC enables functional break teams at zero jade cost. Fugue = optimization for max damage ceilings and comfortable MoC clears. Must-pull status depends on goals—competitive players benefit greatly, casual players can skip if limited. Evaluate based on current performance and jade reserves.

Which has better eidolon value: Fugue or Lingsha?

Fugue's E2 provides 20-25% damage increase (DEF ignore + extended buffs) vs Lingsha's E2 (15-20% personal damage). However, both function optimally at E0. Eidolons show poor resource efficiency vs acquiring new characters. F2P/low-spenders: prioritize E0 copies over eidolons on either.