Identity V | The 9 Survivor Talents Removed in Early Versions and Why They Were Deleted

Since the launch of Identity V, the game has gone through numerous balance adjustments. Just looking at the many talent reworks alone, it’s clear how much effort has been put into tuning the gameplay. Over the years, the following 9 Survivor talents have been removed from the game:

Author: Sarah MitchellSarah Mitchell Publish at: 2025/07/16 3 min read

1. Restlessness

Max Tier: 1
Effect: Increases crouching speed by 40%.
Flavor Text: Like a shark that suffocates if it stops swimming, prey being hunted must stay perpetually restless.
Replaced in 2019 by Survivor's Instinct (Increases decoding speed by 5%/15%/30% when 1/2/3 teammates are eliminated).
Reason for Removal: Spending 5 precious talent points just to move faster while crouching had virtually zero benefit.

  • -22% 6590 Echoeshow to recharge  6590 EchoesUSD 86.35USD 110.34Buy Now
  • -22%6590 Echoes * 8how to recharge 6590 Echoes * 8USD 690.77USD 882.75Buy Now
  • -22%6590 Echoes * 4how to recharge 6590 Echoes * 4USD 345.38USD 441.38Buy Now
  • -22%6590 Echoes * 2how to recharge 6590 Echoes * 2USD 172.69USD 220.69Buy Now
  • -22% 3330 Echoeshow to recharge  3330 EchoesUSD 43.17USD 55.39Buy Now
  • -22% 2025 Echoeshow to recharge  2025 EchoesUSD 25.90USD 33.06Buy Now
  • -23% 690 Echoeshow to recharge  690 EchoesUSD 8.63USD 11.16Buy Now
  • -22% 305 Echoeshow to recharge  305 EchoesUSD 4.31USD 5.54Buy Now
  • -25% 185 Echoeshow to recharge  185 EchoesUSD 2.58USD 3.44Buy Now
  • -27% 60 Echoeshow to recharge  60 EchoesUSD 0.85USD 1.16Buy Now

2. Catfish Effect

Max Tier: 3
Effect: When you're placed on a rocket chair, survivors within a 12/18/24-meter radius gain 4%/6%/8% movement speed.
Flavor Text: Survival competition promotes species continuation.
Replaced in 2020 by Savior Complex (After rescuing a teammate from the rocket chair, gain 5%/10%/15% movement speed for 3 seconds).
Reason for Removal: Its effects were too similar to Herd Mentality, and Savior Complex was a better design to avoid double knockdowns during rescues.

3. Observer

Max Tier: 1
Effect: Gain 10% movement speed when running toward an injured or downed teammate within 25 meters. Increases healing speed by 20% and reveals injured teammates, but does not show ballooned survivors.
Flavor Text: Save no one, and no one will save you.
Removed in 2022, replaced by Flywheel Effect (Dash 3.5 meters forward in the direction the character is facing. Immune to most damage/control effects for 0.4 seconds. 135s cooldown; 50s at start).
Reason for Removal: Considered the most useless core talent at the time and ineffective against the notorious "four-doctor" meta.

4. Hawthorne Effect

Max Tier: 3
Effect: When other survivors are within 5 meters, increase your decoding, healing, and sabotaging speed by 3%/3.5%/4% per teammate.
Flavor Text: People always act differently under the gaze of others.
Replaced in 2019 by Symbiotic Effect (Movement speed increases by 6%–10% when running toward a survivor on a rocket chair. The farther away the teammate, the greater the speed increase).
Reason for Removal: Over-buffed decoding speed when grouped, breaking game balance.

5. Herd Effect

Max Tier: 3
Effect: When other survivors are within 5 meters, their decoding, healing, and sabotaging speed increases by 3%/5%/7%.
Flavor Text: In a foolish herd, there is only one leader.
Replaced in 2019 by Carrion Effect (When a hunter is within 15 meters for 8 seconds, pallet dropping speed increases by 8%/14%/20%).
Reason for Removal: Too similar to the Hawthorne Effect and shared the same balance issues.

6. Tough Guy

Max Tier: 1
Effect: Completely mutes the sound made after taking damage.
Flavor Text: Silence alone doesn't make a tough guy.
Replaced in 2018 by Mechanic Specialization, which was later replaced by Audience Effect (If another survivor is on a rocket chair, decoding speed increases by 8%. This effect is permanently lost after two cipher machines are decoded).
Reason for Removal: Useless in practical gameplay—only helped when trying to hide gameplay from concerned parents who thought the game was too intense.

7. Low Profile

Max Tier: 3
Effect: Reduces the visual effects of vaulting windows and pallets by 8/16/24 meters.
Flavor Text: The loner never wants to be noticed.
Replaced in 2018 by Tenacity (Increases recovery speed while downed by 10%/15%/20%; crawling speed increases by 30%/60%/90%).
Reason for Removal: Provided minimal gameplay benefit.

8. Scarecrow

Max Tier: 3
Effect: Reduces the chance of startling crows by 70%/85%/100%.
Flavor Text: Crows don’t actually like scarecrows—they prefer meat.
Replaced in 2018 by Healing (Reduces the time it takes to be healed by others by 15%. Also grants slow auto-recovery when injured, at a rate of 0.3%/0.45%/0.6% per second, up to 30%/45%/60%).
Reason for Removal: Extremely low utility.

9. Compulsive

Max Tier: 1
Effect: Reveals chests within a 16-meter radius.
Flavor Text: Never pass up a chance to rummage through a box.
Removed in 2022
Reason for Removal: No practical benefit.

Thank you for reading! Wishing you plenty of golden luck and smooth victories ahead!

Share

Recommended News

10 Years Trusted Game & Live Streaming Top-Up Platform

Since 2016 | 5,000,000+ Users Worldwide

KAMAGEN LIMITED

Room 1508, 15/F, Grand Plaza Office Tower II, 625 Nathan Road, Mong Kok, Kowloon, Hong Kong

BUSINESS COOPERATION: ibittopup@gmail.com

© 2016-2026 BitTopup. All Rights Reserved.

Trusted & Verified by

ScamAdviser review of BitTopupGridinsoft review of BitTopupTrustpilot review of BitTopup
customer service